What is the law on dating subscription auto renewal in the US?
Dating subscription auto renewal law in the US is a federal baseline, ROSCA, with stricter state laws on top. Most dating memberships renew until the member cancels, so these rules apply to almost every paid dating brand that takes US members.
| Rule | In force from | What it adds |
|---|---|---|
| ROSCA (federal) | Enacted December 2010 | Clear terms before billing, express informed consent, simple cancellation |
| FTC click to cancel rule | Vacated 8 July 2025 | Nothing at present; a new rulemaking began in March 2026 |
| California Automatic Renewal Law | Amendments from 1 July 2025 | Separate consent, online cancellation, save offer limits, annual reminders, price change notices |
| Minnesota | 1 January 2025 | Covers social referral services; yearly notice; limits on retention offers |
| Massachusetts (940 CMR 38) | 2 September 2025 | Cancel by the same website or app; reminders before renewal |
| Connecticut | 1 October 2025 | Tighter "clear and conspicuous" test; more changes from July 2026 |
| New York | 5 November 2025 | Price rise notices, consent or refund on price rises, trial reminders |
| Colorado (SB25-145) | 16 February 2026 | One-step online cancellation; visible cancel link during save offers |
This page covers renewals only. For the wider picture see US dating site legal requirements and the state safety laws in US dating site regulations. This is general information, not legal advice.
What does ROSCA require?
ROSCA requires three things before you charge for an online subscription that renews automatically. The statute (15 U.S.C. 8403) says you must:
- Clearly and conspicuously disclose all material terms before you collect billing information.
- Get the consumer's express informed consent before you charge their card or account.
- Provide simple mechanisms for the consumer to stop recurring charges.
Jones Day notes that ROSCA does not define "material terms" or "simple mechanism", so FTC cases fill the gap. It cites settlements with Care.com ($8.5 million) and Amazon ($2.5 billion), both brought under the FTC Act and ROSCA over unclear terms and hard cancellation. For a dating brand, material terms means at least the price, the billing frequency, the fact that it renews, when the first charge falls after any trial, and how to cancel.
Is the FTC click to cancel rule in force?
No. The FTC adopted an amended Negative Option Rule in October 2024, and the Eighth Circuit vacated all of it on 8 July 2025 in Custom Communications, Inc. v. FTC. Latham and Watkins reports that the court found the FTC had skipped a required preliminary regulatory analysis, and that the ruling came days before full compliance was due on 14 July 2025.
The FTC has started again:
- A Federal Register notice says the FTC restored the pre-2024 rule on 12 February 2026. That older rule deals with plans that ship goods unless the customer declines, not with online dating memberships.
- On 11 March 2026 the FTC asked for comment on a new advance notice of proposed rulemaking. Covington reports it was published on 13 March 2026, with comments due by 13 April 2026.
- The notice asks whether to revive parts of the vacated rule, consider other approaches, or treat some industries differently.
We found no proposed rule published by the date we checked. Watch ftc.gov, and build to ROSCA and the state laws now.
What does California's automatic renewal law require?
California requires separate consent to the renewal terms, online cancellation for online sign-ups, and a set of reminders. The amendments apply to contracts entered into, amended or extended on or after 1 July 2025, and they now cover free trials that turn into paid plans.
From section 17602 and the Attorney General's September 2025 alert:
- Consent. Get express affirmative consent to the renewal terms, separate from the rest of the offer. Keep proof for three years, or one year after the contract ends if that is longer.
- Acknowledgment. Send a confirmation the member can keep, with the terms, the cancellation policy and how to cancel.
- Online cancellation. A member who joined online must be able to cancel online, at will, through a prominently placed direct link or button (for example in account settings) or an immediately available cancellation email.
- Save offers. You may show a discount or explain what the member will lose, but online a "click to cancel" link or button must stay prominent alongside the offer.
- Reminders. Notice 3 to 21 days before a trial or promotional price of more than 31 days ends; 15 to 45 days before renewal of an initial term of a year or more; and an annual reminder of the charge and how to cancel.
- Price changes. Notice 7 to 30 days before a price rise, with cancellation instructions.
What do New York and other states add?
They add price rise rules, reminders and cancel-anywhere duties that partly overlap with California. Perkins Coie reports that New York's amendments took effect on 5 November 2025:
- Notice of a price rise 5 to 30 days before it applies, by the method the member chose.
- Either the member's affirmative consent to the higher price, or a right to cancel within 14 days of the first higher charge with a prorated refund.
- Cancellation through every medium in which a member can consent.
- For trials longer than one month, a reminder 3 to 21 days before the cancellation deadline.
Elsewhere:
- Minnesota names social referral services in its scope, requires a yearly notice of the terms and how to cancel, and restricts retention offers unless the consumer has agreed, according to Kelley Drye.
- Massachusetts requires cancellation through the same website or app used to join. For terms of 31 days or less, the reminder can be a receipt at each charge with the amount and how to cancel.
- Colorado requires a one-step online cancellation link, which must stay visible during any save offer.
What do Visa and Mastercard require?
The card schemes add their own rules, and your acquirer enforces them. Visa's trial subscription rules, in force since 18 April 2020, require:
- Express agreement to an ongoing subscription at sign-up.
- A copy of the terms by email or text, even when nothing is charged up front, with a cancellation link.
- A reminder at least 7 days before the first charge after a trial or introductory price ends, or before a price or billing change.
- An easy way to cancel online, however the member joined.
- A "trial" descriptor on the first charge after the trial.
Mastercard's summary, in force since 11 October 2022, asks for clear terms at enrolment, a confirmation email, a receipt after every billing, a notice 7 days before each annual billing, and online cancellation. These rules tie into chargeback risk, covered in our guide to dating site chargebacks.
What should the sign-up and cancel flows include?
Build one flow to the strictest rule and use it in every state. That is simpler than switching by zip code.
Sign-up:
- Price, billing frequency, renewal term, first charge date after any trial, and how to cancel, next to the pay button.
- A separate, unticked consent to automatic renewal.
- A confirmation email with the terms and a cancel link.
- A timestamped record of the wording the member saw.
During the subscription:
- A trial reminder at least 7 days before the first charge.
- A receipt after every charge.
- A price rise notice 7 to 30 days ahead, with consent or a refund route.
- An annual reminder for long terms.
Cancel:
- A visible cancel button in account settings, reachable in one or two clicks.
- At most one save offer, with the cancel button still on screen.
- An instant on-screen and email confirmation.
Our guide to dating free trial offers covers how to design trials that convert without causing disputes.
Who runs renewals on a white label platform?
The platform usually runs billing, renewals and cancellations, so most of this checklist sits with it. You still own any price or trial promise in your adverts and landing pages.
On Dating Partners, our sister company run by the same group as this site, the platform runs payments, refunds, chargebacks and support for every brand, and you are paid 50% of revenue from each member you bring. Our payments and customer care page explains how. It is a website platform only, so it does not help if you want to run your own billing.
Questions to ask any provider:
- Does cancellation work online, in one step, for every member?
- Which reminders are sent, and when?
- How long is proof of consent kept?
- Who handles a state attorney general's enquiry about renewals?
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Ask a US lawyer to check your flows.
Questions
Do these laws apply to monthly dating subscriptions?
Yes. ROSCA and the state laws cover subscriptions that renew until cancelled, whatever the term. Some duties, such as California's 15 to 45 day renewal notice, apply only to initial terms of a year or more.
Can I offer a discount when a member tries to cancel?
Usually, yes, if it does not obstruct the cancellation. California and Colorado require a cancel link to stay visible while you show the offer, and Minnesota restricts retention offers unless the member has agreed to hear them.
Do app store subscriptions follow the same rules?
When members pay through Apple or Google, the store runs billing and cancellation through its own settings. You are still responsible for what your sign-up screens say about price and renewal, so take advice on how the state laws apply.
How long should I keep proof of consent?
California requires proof of affirmative consent for at least three years, or one year after the contract ends, whichever is longer. Keeping a timestamped record of the screen and wording the member saw is a sensible default.
Sources
- 15 U.S.C. 8403, Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act (Cornell LII), checked 21 November 2026
- Latham and Watkins: Eighth Circuit vacates FTC click to cancel rule days before compliance deadline, checked 21 November 2026
- FTC: FTC seeks public comment in response to advance notice of proposed rulemaking regarding negative option (March 2026), checked 21 November 2026
- Covington: FTC launches new rulemaking on the Negative Option Rule, checked 21 November 2026
- Federal Register: FTC information collection notice on the Negative Option Rule, 14 October 2026, checked 21 November 2026
- Jones Day: FTC revives click to cancel rule, new risks for subscription businesses (May 2026), checked 21 November 2026
- California Business and Professions Code section 17602 (FindLaw), checked 21 November 2026
- California Attorney General: consumer alert on California's Automatic Renewal Law (4 September 2025), checked 21 November 2026
- Venable: California amends autorenewal law, with stricter consent requirements and a one save rule, checked 21 November 2026
- Perkins Coie: New York and Colorado update auto renewing subscription requirements, checked 21 November 2026
- Kelley Drye: NY quietly amends automatic renewal law, checked 21 November 2026
- Kelley Drye: Auto renewal laws, 2025 round up, checked 21 November 2026
- Covington Inside Privacy: States press forward with automatic renewal laws amidst vacating of the FTC's Negative Option Rule, checked 21 November 2026
- Visa: Trial subscription updates (merchant flier), checked 21 November 2026
- Mastercard: Subscription and negative option billing model summary, checked 21 November 2026
- Dating Partners partner terms, checked 21 November 2026
What changed
- : First published.