From High Intent Media, the group behind Smooch, Just Singles, Dating Partners and DatingAPI. We say where our products fit, and where they do not.Facts and sources
Talk to us
Guide · Growth

The cold start problem for dating apps and how to solve it

Short answer

The cold start problem is that a dating app is only worth joining once enough suitable people nearby are already on it. A new member who opens an empty app leaves and rarely comes back. The honest fixes are to launch in one small, dense group, hold a waitlist until an area is ready, or join a shared member network.

By the White Label Dating teamLast checked 8 minute read

This site is run by High Intent Media, which also runs Dating Partners and DatingAPI. Both may be mentioned on this page. Editorial policy

What is the cold start problem for a dating app?

It is the problem that a dating app has almost no value to a new member until other members are already there. Andreessen Horowitz, the venture firm of Andrew Chen, who wrote The Cold Start Problem, describes a network effect as "where a product or service's value increases as more users engage with it". A dating app is a pure case. The product is the other people.

Dating makes the problem harder than it is for most networks, for three reasons.

  • It is local. A member in Leeds gains nothing from members in Lisbon. You need enough people in each place, not in total.
  • Filters shrink the pool. Age range, distance and who a member wants to meet each cut the number of profiles they can see.
  • Balance matters. If one group is in short supply, the other group runs out of people to talk to, however many sign up.

So the real question is never "how many members do we have?" It is "what does a new member in this town see today?"

Why does an empty app lose new members?

Because a new member judges the app in their first session, and an empty screen tells them there is nobody here. They do not wait for it to fill up. They close it and try a bigger app.

The damage builds on itself:

  1. The first search comes back thin. A handful of profiles, or the same faces again the next day.
  2. Messages go unanswered. The few people shown are inactive or far away.
  3. The member leaves. That makes the app emptier for the next person who joins.
  4. Marketing money is wasted. You paid to bring in someone the product could not serve.
  5. Reviews suffer. Disappointed members say so in the app stores.

The stores notice too. Apple's guideline 4.3(b) names dating as a saturated category and says Apple may remove apps that "do not attract customers". Our guide to app store rules for dating apps explains that rule.

How did Tinder get past its cold start?

Tinder started with one campus, not one country. According to TechCrunch's interview with Andrew Chen, the first version had good features, but friends who were invited one by one did not stick. The fix was a party at a university campus where guests had to download the app to get in. TechCrunch reports that co-founder Sean Rad credited "those 500 people" with helping the app take over the campus.

Entrepreneur tells a similar story with slightly different figures: about 300 people at the University of Southern California to begin with, and 1,000 by the end of that week. It says co-founder Whitney Wolfe then visited sorority chapters around the country, and membership had reached almost 15,000 by the time she returned. These are figures from interviews, not audited numbers.

Two lessons carry over to any dating brand.

  • Density beats size. A few hundred people who know the same places and might really meet are worth more than thousands spread thinly.
  • Win the group that is hardest to attract first. In his book, Chen calls this the hard side of a network. He writes that women on Tinder swiped right on about 5% of profiles, against about 45% for men. An app has to feel safe and worth the time for the people who are most selective.

What are the honest ways to solve the cold start problem?

There are five, and they can be combined. Each one puts enough real people in front of a new member on day one.

MethodHow it worksSuitsWatch out for
One small, dense groupLaunch in a single city, campus or community and stay there until it worksNew apps with a clear audienceSlow headline growth; you must resist going national early
Waitlist by areaCollect sign-ups, then open each area when enough people are waitingBrands with press or social reachPeople lose interest if the wait is long or unexplained
Events and partnersBring people into the app together, at an event or through a club, venue or publicationLocal and niche brandsHard to repeat in every town
An audience you already haveInvite readers, listeners, followers or members of another productMedia owners and communitiesThe audience may be spread across many places
A shared member networkYour members can meet members who joined other brands on the same platformNew brands and niches that need critical massLess control, and members must be told

Whichever you choose, aim marketing at one area at a time. Our guide to getting your first 1,000 members covers the channels, and the guide to waitlist strategies covers opening area by area.

What should you never do to make a dating app look busy?

Never fill the app with profiles that are not real members. It is tempting, and it is the fastest way to lose members' trust and attract a regulator.

  • No fake or staff-run profiles. The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) says dating businesses should not mislead customers by creating their own dating profiles to communicate with them.
  • No automated flirting. In 2014 JDI Dating agreed to pay $616,165 to settle US Federal Trade Commission charges. The FTC said the company sent members messages from computer-generated profiles to push them to subscribe.
  • No inflated member counts. The CMA says claims about how many members you have should be based on "the number of regular users", not on everyone who has ever joined.
  • No bought lists. People who did not choose to join your brand are not members.

A quiet app that is honest can be fixed. One caught faking activity is much harder to rescue. This is general information, not legal advice.

How does a shared member network solve the cold start?

It lets a new brand open with real members already there, because your members can meet people who joined other brands on the same platform. It is the only method on the list that works from the first day in every area the network covers.

The network run by our group offers three settings, which can differ by country. They are described on our member network page.

  • Private. Members see only people who joined your brand.
  • Backfill. Members see your own members first, then network members where your area is quiet.
  • Shared. Your members and the network's members see each other, both ways.

We should be clear about who this fits. Dating Partners, our sister company run by the same group as this site, puts new website brands on a shared network so that partners have members from day one. It is for dating websites only. DatingAPI, also run by our group, offers the network as an option for apps, but it suits brands that already have an audience. A first-time app with no members should look at the other methods first.

A shared network has real trade-offs:

  • Less control. The network sets the matching and moderation rules.
  • Members must be told. The CMA says a dating business should explain data sharing with other dating websites, list them and get permission.
  • Coverage varies. A network can be thin in your niche or country. Ask for a count of active members in your top cities before you commit.
  • Your brand still has to earn its place. A shared pool gives members someone to meet. It does not give them a reason to choose you.

Our guide to shared dating networks goes through these in detail.

How do you know when the cold start is over?

It is over in an area when new members there get a good first week without your help. Measure it area by area, not across the whole app.

  • Profiles on first search. How many suitable profiles does a new member see with typical filters?
  • First reply. What share of new members get a reply or a match in their first few days?
  • Return visits. Do members in this area come back in week two?
  • Sign-ups without adverts. Are people arriving by word of mouth?

There is no published benchmark that fits every app, so compare your areas with each other. When one area holds up, copy the method to the next. Our guide to dating app analytics covers how to track this.

Questions

How many members does a dating app need before it works?

There is no published number that fits every app. It depends on how tight your niche is and how far members will travel. Measure whether a new member in each area sees enough suitable profiles and gets a reply in their first few days.

Is the cold start problem worse for niche dating apps?

Yes and no. A narrow niche has fewer people in any one town, so each area fills slowly. But a niche audience is easier to find in one place, such as a community, a publication or an event, which is how you build density.

Can paid advertising solve a cold start?

Only if it is aimed at one area or group at a time. Adverts spread across a whole country bring in members who cannot see each other, and most of that spend is lost.

Should I launch a website before an app?

Often, yes. A website is quicker to launch and can join a shared network from day one, so you can prove your audience before you pay for an app.

Do members mind being on a shared network?

They should be told clearly. The UK Competition and Markets Authority says a dating business should explain data sharing with other dating websites, list those websites and get permission.

Sources

  1. TechCrunch: Andrew Chen of a16z on how startups get past a cold start to survive and thrive, checked 20 November 2026
  2. Andreessen Horowitz: The Cold Start Problem, by Andrew Chen, checked 20 November 2026
  3. Andrew Chen: Solve a Hard Problem (Tinder), chapter 8 of The Cold Start Problem, checked 20 November 2026
  4. Entrepreneur: 1 Billion Matches Later, Tinder Can Trace Its To-the-Moon Growth to Signing Up Sorority Girls, checked 20 November 2026
  5. CMA: Online dating and consumer law, advice for business, checked 20 November 2026
  6. FTC business blog: Dating advice from the FTC (JDI Dating settlement), checked 20 November 2026
  7. Apple: App Review Guidelines, checked 20 November 2026
  8. Dating Partners partner terms, checked 20 November 2026
  9. DatingAPI, checked 20 November 2026

What changed

  • : First published.

Planning a dating app?

New brand or existing app, there is a route for each.

Compare the app routes